100% INDEPENDENT · 0% SPONSORED

The definitive ranking of blueberry muffins in NYC.

Honest ratings, no fluff. We eat the muffins, score them with a consistent methodology, and publish the results.

Last updated May 18, 2025

5 muffins · 5 boroughs

Every muffin scored on a consistent 6-criteria methodology.

No paid placements. No sponsored rankings. Ever.

We re-visit bakeries regularly to keep scores current.

All five boroughs. No neighborhood left behind.

Rankings

5 muffins ranked

Park Slope, Brooklyn

A dense, buttery crumb studded with plump berries that burst with every bite.

Upper West Side, Manhattan

Oversized and satisfying, with a crisp exterior and a soft, berry-rich interior.

East Village, Manhattan

Playful and sweet with a cakey texture and generous blueberry distribution.

Cobble Hill, Brooklyn

French-inspired elegance in muffin form — tender crumb, subtle sweetness.

Astoria, Queens

A neighborhood favorite with a classic bakery feel and reliable berry ratio.